Home / Structured Settlements / Non-Qualified Annuities in Taxable Settlement Cases

Non-Qualified Annuities in Taxable Settlement Cases

Key Takeaways

  • Non-qualified annuities allow clients to defer taxes on investment growth until distributions are taken.
  • Tax deferral enables greater accumulation compared to taxable investment accounts.
  • Only earnings are taxed, while principal is returned tax-free.
  • Proper structuring helps clients control the timing of taxable income.

Meet the Author

Greg Maxwell, Esq. CFP®

Greg Maxwell is an attorney, Certified Financial Planner, and settlement planner. He specializes in settlement tax planning, government benefits planning, and financial planning for plaintiffs and plaintiff attorneys.

Are You or Your Client Receiving a Settlement Soon?

Book a free 15-minute call to review settlement planning options and help make sure you or your client make the most of the settlement.

Book a FREE call today to start your tax strategy & financial planning with settlement experts. Avoid costly mistakes, reduce taxes, and make the most of your settlement.

Book a FREE call today to start your tax strategy & financial planning with settlement experts.

Search for “non-qualified annuity” and nearly every result describes a retirement product sold by insurance agents. In a lawsuit settlement, the same term describes a way for a plaintiff to receive a taxable recovery as scheduled payments over several years.

That option matters to plaintiffs, their families, and the attorneys handling taxable cases.

Spreading the income across several years may lower the total tax on the recovery, provided the payments are arranged as part of the settlement before any money is paid.

I have spent more than 20 years helping plaintiffs and their attorneys plan settlements, including taxable ones. Below, I explain how these payments work, which claims may qualify, and what must happen before signing.

TL;DR: Non-Qualified Annuities in Taxable Settlements

The main points about non-qualified annuities in taxable settlements are:

  • ●A non-qualified annuity in a settlement is a structured settlement annuity that pays out a taxable recovery over time.
  • ●The defendant or its insurer funds it as part of the settlement agreement, often through an assignment company that owns the annuity.
  • ●Each payment is generally taxed as ordinary income in the year you receive it, provided the structure is properly arranged.
  • ●Spreading taxable income over several years may lower your total taxes paid by lowering your tax bracket.
  • ●Eligible non-wage claims may use this structure, while wage portions such as back pay usually cannot.
  • ●The structure must be arranged before you receive the funds or gain the right to access them. Money held for you in your attorney’s trust account can count as received.
  • ●The payment schedule is generally fixed at settlement, so it should fit your needs before you sign.
TALK TO US
Receiving a settlement soon?
Book a free 15-minute call before you receive your funds to explore options and avoid costly mistakes.

Book a free call →

What a Non-Qualified Annuity Means in a Settlement

A structured settlement annuity pays a plaintiff’s settlement over time through an annuity issued by a life insurance company.

The words “qualified” and “non-qualified” describe which tax rules govern the transfer of the obligation to make those payments.

The difference comes down to how that payment obligation is transferred:

  • ●Qualified assignment: Under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 130, this applies to periodic payments in a case involving physical injury or physical sickness, including workers’ compensation. The payments must also be excludable from income under IRC Section 104(a)(1) or (a)(2).
  • ●Nonqualified assignment: A taxable recovery cannot use a qualified assignment. Instead, an assignment company assumes the future-payment obligation and owns the annuity used to fund it.

The retail non-qualified annuity in most search results is a different product. A person buys that kind of annuity on their own, with money they already have.

A plaintiff cannot buy a structured settlement annuity that way. A structured settlement annuity can only be established as part of the settlement agreement.

Qualified vs. Non-Qualified Structured Settlement Annuities

The two types differ mainly in the claims they cover and how each payment is taxed:

Feature Qualified structured settlement Non-qualified structured settlement
Typical claims Personal physical injury, physical sickness, and workers’ compensation for a physical injury or sickness Eligible taxable claims, such as certain employment, defamation, and contract claims
Transfer of the payment obligation Qualified assignment under IRC Section 130 Nonqualified assignment
Tax on each payment Generally excluded from income, provided the settlement qualifies Generally ordinary income when received, if properly structured; depends on the underlying claim
What the tax result depends on Meeting the Section 104 exclusion and the Section 130 requirements Avoiding actual or constructive receipt and meeting the applicable economic-benefit rules

The non-qualified column assumes a properly arranged structured settlement of eligible non-wage claims. Not every taxable recovery qualifies for this treatment.

Taxable Claims That May Use a Non-Qualified Annuity

Outside the Section 104 exclusion, a settlement is generally taxable unless another exclusion applies.

Claims that often produce taxable recoveries include:

  • ●Employment claims: Non-wage damages in discrimination, retaliation, and wrongful termination cases are generally taxable.
  • ●Defamation claims: Damages for harm to your reputation generally fall outside the physical injury exclusion.
  • ●Breach of contract and business disputes: Recoveries for contract damages or lost profits are generally taxable.
  • ●Professional malpractice without physical injury: Recoveries in legal, accounting, or financial malpractice cases can be taxable, depending on what the underlying loss was.
  • ●Emotional distress without physical injury: Damages for emotional distress are taxable unless they flow from a physical injury or physical sickness. Amounts that reimburse medical care for the distress may be excluded, except to the extent a prior deduction for those expenses provided a tax benefit.
  • ●Punitive damages: Punitive damages generally fall outside the physical injury exclusion, even when the rest of an injury settlement is tax-free.

Whether a particular claim can be structured depends on the claim and the settlement terms. How the recovery is allocated also matters.

Back pay and other wage portions are generally treated as wages and usually fall outside this kind of structure.

The settlement agreement should separate wage and non-wage amounts so the eligible portion is clear.

FREE TOOL
Will You Owe Taxes on Your Settlement?
Estimate how much tax you may owe before you receive your settlement.

Try the tax calculator →

How a Non-Qualified Annuity Can Lower the Tax on a Taxable Recovery

A structure changes when a taxable recovery is taxed. That timing can change how much of it is taxed at the highest rates.

Two parts of the tax picture shape how much a structure may help:

Income Spread Across Several Tax Years

Federal income tax is progressive. Income above each bracket threshold is taxed at a higher rate.

A large taxable recovery received in one year can push much of that year’s income into the top brackets.

A structure lets you receive the recovery in scheduled payments instead. If the structure is properly arranged, each payment is generally taxed as ordinary income, meaning at your regular income tax rates, in the year you receive it.

On the taxable cases I work on, reducing how much income lands in the highest bracket in a single year is one of the primary benefits of a structure.

That deferral depends on two tax rules:

  • ●Constructive receipt: Income counts as received once it is credited to you, set apart for you, or otherwise made available for you to draw on. The exception is when your control over it is subject to substantial limitations or restrictions.
  • ●Economic benefit: Money that is irrevocably set aside for your benefit can be treated as income right away.

Setting future payment dates in the agreement is not enough by itself.

Non-Deductible Legal Fees and the Double Tax Trap

When a recovery is taxable, your gross income generally includes the contingency fee paid to your attorney. The Supreme Court confirmed this general rule in Commissioner v. Banks.

Before 2018, plaintiffs without another deduction could generally claim those fees as a miscellaneous itemized deduction. That deduction was subject to a 2% floor and alternative minimum tax limits.

The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 eliminated the miscellaneous itemized deduction beginning in 2018. The One Big Beautiful Bill, signed into law on July 4, 2025, made that change permanent.

IRC Section 67 now disallows these deductions for any tax year beginning after 2017.

The result is what we call the Plaintiff Double Tax Trap. You pay tax on the fee portion of your recovery, while your attorney pays tax on that same fee as income.

The double tax trap can apply to taxable cases such as defamation, malpractice, and breach of contract when the legal fees do not qualify for another deduction or tax treatment.

Some claims still qualify for an above-the-line deduction, which subtracts the fees before your adjusted gross income is calculated. IRC Section 62 provides it for several categories, including:

  • ●Unlawful discrimination claims: The statute defines this term broadly enough to reach claims regulating the employment relationship.
  • ●Certain whistleblower awards: Attorney fees tied to qualifying awards can also be deducted above the line.

For unlawful discrimination claims, the deduction cannot exceed the settlement income you include for the same tax year. That limit applies whether the recovery is paid as a lump sum or in periodic payments.

If part of an employment recovery is structured, the fee timing and the payment schedule should be planned together.

A structure can help with the timing of the portion you receive over time. The tax on the fee portion needs its own planning.

Our settlement tax planning team can help you or your client review strategies to plan for non-deductible legal fees alongside a structure. You can then compare the combined after-tax result before the agreement is signed.

How a Non-Qualified Annuity Is Set Up in a Settlement

Each step of a non-qualified structure happens during settlement negotiations, before any funds are paid:

1. Identifying the Eligible Portion of the Recovery

The first step is to separate the claims in the case. From there, you can decide which taxable, non-wage portion could be structured.

An allocation in the settlement agreement is generally respected when it reflects the substance of the settled claims. A label by itself does not change how a payment is taxed.

Our proprietary Settlement Tax Calculator can estimate the tax on a settlement. The calculator compares a lump sum with payments spread over several years.

2. Designing the Payment Schedule Before Settlement

Every plan I build starts with what the plaintiff will need each year. I also look at what other income will cover near-term expenses.

Common payout designs include:

  • ●Lifetime income: Monthly payments continue for the rest of your life.
  • ●Fixed period: Yearly payments continue for a set number of years.
  • ●Fixed period plus lifetime income: Yearly payments for a set number of years are followed by payments for life.
  • ●Planned lump sums: Larger amounts arrive at specific ages or dates you choose at settlement.

The schedule chosen at settlement is generally the schedule you keep, so build it around your needs and goals.

Scheduled increases can also be built in at settlement.

3. Adding the Structure to the Settlement Agreement

The structured payment terms must be established as part of the settlement agreement, along with the assignment documents.

Your attorney should review the release and assignment language before anyone signs.

Timing is the deciding rule. The structured portion must be arranged before you receive the funds or gain the right to access them.

Receipt by your attorney on your behalf, including through a trust account, can count as receipt by you. The result depends on your rights to the funds and any restrictions on access.

Once the funds are received, the option is generally no longer available for that money.

4. Funding Through a Nonqualified Assignment

At closing, the defendant or its insurer pays the structured amount, often to an assignment company. That portion is not paid to you or your attorney.

The assignment company then buys an annuity from a life insurance company to fund the payment schedule.

You hold the right to receive each scheduled payment on the date set in the agreement. Each payment is generally taxable in the year it arrives, so the schedule also guides your tax planning.

Risks and Trade-Offs to Weigh Before Structuring

The main limits of a non-qualified structure to weigh against the potential tax savings are:

  • ●Limited access to the money: The payment schedule is generally fixed at settlement. You usually cannot speed up payments to cover a large expense later.
  • ●Ordinary income each year: Each payment is generally taxable when received. Future tax rates and your other income may differ from what you expect today.
  • ●Setup errors: An improperly arranged structure can trigger tax before the scheduled payments arrive.
  • ●Reliance on the payers: Your payments depend on the assignment company and the life insurance company that issues the annuity meeting their obligations.
  • ●Inflation: Level payments buy less over time unless scheduled increases are built in at settlement.

For these reasons, the plans I build usually place only part of a taxable recovery into a structure.

The rest stays in cash or investments for near-term needs.

When a Non-Qualified Annuity Fits a Plaintiff’s Situation

In my experience, a structure tends to fit when the recovery is large enough to raise your tax bracket. You also need to be able to wait for part of the money.

The situations where I most often see it make sense include:

  • ●A large taxable recovery in one year: A recovery that would push your income into higher brackets for that year may benefit from spreading it out.
  • ●Other income for near-term needs: You or your household have wages, savings, or other funds to cover expenses while the payments begin.
  • ●Predictable future needs: You want steady income for retirement, education, or ongoing expenses.
  • ●Time before the agreement is final: There is still time to design the schedule and add it to the settlement agreement.

A structure may be a poor fit in these situations:

  • ●Immediate needs: You need most of the money right away.
  • ●Small taxable amount: The taxable portion is too small for spreading it out to make a meaningful difference.
  • ●Mostly wages: The recovery consists mainly of wages.

Our structured settlements team can help design a structure tailored to the specific circumstances of the case. We can also show you or your client how the after-tax numbers compare with a lump sum before anything is signed.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

These questions come up often in my conversations about structuring taxable recoveries:

Are Non-Qualified Annuity Payments Taxable?+

In a settlement, each payment from a non-qualified structure is generally taxed as ordinary income in the year you receive it, provided the structure is properly arranged. The exact treatment depends on the underlying claim.

Can Back Pay From an Employment Settlement Go Into a Non-Qualified Annuity?+

Back pay is generally treated as wages. Wage portions usually fall outside this kind of structure. Non-wage portions of the same settlement, such as emotional distress damages, may be eligible if the agreement allocates them in a way that reflects the substance of the claims.

Can a Non-Qualified Annuity Be Set Up After the Settlement Money Arrives?+

Generally no, for money you have already received or gained the right to access. Funds held for you in your attorney’s trust account can count as received, depending on your rights to them. The structured portion has to be arranged as part of the settlement agreement before that point.

Can One Settlement Include Both a Tax-Free and a Taxable Structured Annuity?+

One settlement may include both when the case resolves physical injury claims and taxable claims. The tax-free portion may use a qualified assignment, while the taxable portion may use a nonqualified assignment. The allocation between them should reflect the substance of the settled claims.

Is a Settlement Annuity the Same as a Non-Qualified Annuity From an Insurance Agent?+

No, they are different products that happen to share a name. A retail non-qualified annuity is something a person buys with their own money. A structured settlement annuity can only be created as part of a settlement agreement and is funded by the defendant or its insurer.

Conclusion

A non-qualified annuity changes when you pay tax on a taxable recovery. Spreading that income over several years may lower the total you pay. The decision has to be made before the settlement is signed and the money is paid.

Amicus Settlement Planners was built by attorneys to help plaintiffs. Our attorneys, CFP® professionals, and CPA help plaintiffs and law firms nationwide with the tax, legal, and financial decisions at settlement.

We can help you or your client decide how much of a taxable recovery to structure. We can also help design a payment schedule tailored to the specific circumstances of the case.

Contact our team to request a free 15-minute call and see how a structure could fit your settlement.

NEXT STEP
Plan Before You Receive Your Settlement
Talk with Amicus about the tax, government benefits, and planning decisions that should be made before you receive your settlement.

Book a free call →

You May Also Like...